High School Musical Fruit?

Oh my stars. After years of slapping images of their characters on everything from Happy Meals to Froot Snacks, Disney’s gone all healthy on us.  The Washington Post reports that they’ve expanded licensing images of their characters for packaging on fruits and vegetables — from Zac Efron avocadoes to Winnie the Pooh apples. Maybe Disney tired of the criticism they’d earned via their billion-dollar decade-long contract with McDonalds, or maybe they just didn’t want to keep re-engineering the rides at their theme parks to accommodate our nation’s expanding girth.

Either way, it’s totally messing with my head.

When I first heard, I was like, “Huh. Well. I guess….”

Then I was all, “Bah! They don’t care about kids’ health! It’s all about reputation and bottom line!”

Then I’m all, “Who cares? Remember when kids liked carrots better simply because they had the McDonald’s logo on ‘em? This actually could help bump up consumption of healthful foods!”

Then I’m all, “Oh, but I work so hard to avoid corporate merchandising! And now it’s in the produce aisle, too?”

Then I’m all, “Yeah, but check this out: bagged-apple sales went up 47 percent during a High School Musical promotion at Winn-Dixie! And remember Popeye? That funny-looking bald dude alone increased spinach consumption by a third, and he didn’t even have the Disney marketing machine behind him!”

Them I’m all, “Aww, but with all due respect to Disney — or Freud, for that matter — can’t a banana just be a banana sometimes?”

Then I’m all, “Hate to break it to you, Ali, but you know that wee Charlotte would more gladly eat a banana if it was a Cinderella banana.”

Then I’m all, “But homogenization of food! Food miles! Where is the small? The sustainable? The regional?”

Then I’m all, “Come on. Isn’t this what we wanted companies to do? To stop marketing junk? To start promoting something that was in kids’ best interests?”

Then I’m all, “But sustainable food IS in kids’ best interests! I know it is!”

Then I’m all, “Yeah, well you also know what it’s like to be in a grocery store with a hungry kid that’s ripping a box of Pop Tarts off the shelves simply because she sees Barbie smiling at her from the box. This way, you can wave a piece of SpongeBob fruit in front of her face as a distraction. At least it’s a whole food, yo!”

Then I’m all, “But is it really a choice between marketing one thing, or marketing another? Isn’t that a false choice, when you think about it?”

Then I’m all, “Well, maybe the false choice is the one between ‘good food’ and ‘corporate food,’ Missy. Maybe the perfect really is the enemy of the good. These products are getting kids to nag their parents for healthy food for a change!”

Then I’m all, “I…I guess I…well, I mean…I think I just really wanted to tone down the merchandising altogether. I mean, can’t we simply decide that they’re kids and not consumers?”

Then I’m all, “Hahahaha! You’re really funny!”And so weird!!” (insert knee-slapping and shaking with laughter here. Then, after a few minutes of laughing so hard that tears roll down my cheeks, I get all serious again). “Seriously, this is America, yo.”

And then my brain kind of explodes and I putter around the room touching random objects and forget what I had been doing five minutes before.

So what do you guys think? Sign of newfound corporate responsibility? Sign of the apocalypse? Please discuss.

12 Responses to “High School Musical Fruit?”


  1. 1 JessTrev May 4, 2009 at 6:21 pm

    I think I love your blog more and more each day as you reveal your hair splitting tendencies. Not such a black and white world….

    Marketing – ack! Nutrition – yes!

    And as a good friend used to say to me when I bemoaned the omnipresent children’s show marketing, you don’t have to watch a show for a little person to feel involved in it. So, unless you are better than me at locking your children into their closets, they may be aware of some of this marketing that is not going away. You can just add this to your toolkit of stuff besides the dogeared copy of Thomas you got at a yardsale to keep your kids happy and feeling involved in their peer group without actually having to go through the trip to Orlando. ;)

  2. 2 Frances May 4, 2009 at 6:57 pm

    The inside of your head sounds a lot like the inside of my head. I shudder to think how much worse it’s going to get if I have kids. Until then, I prefer to consider — in the abstract — the effect of marketing on kids. I hate any situation in which you have to make the “Well, even if it [bad thing], isn’t it okay that it [good thing]?” rationalization.

    It is (unbelievably) quite old now, but you might enjoy reading some pieces from an old favorite (maga)zine, Stay Free, from April 1997.

    http://www.ibiblio.org/pub/electronic-publications/stay-free/archives/13/index.html

  3. 3 Meredith May 4, 2009 at 7:28 pm

    Finally! I’m ahead of Disney! (I know, probably something I shouldn’t be too proud of.)

    About six years ago we bought Spongebob baby carrots for my daughter. She loved them so I started buying new foods for her to try but before I gave them to her I would “brand” them with a character sticker. She wasn’t crazy about the Sleeping Beauty blackberries but loved the Pocahontas asparagus. Just this morning my son went off to the sitter with a “You’re A Really Useful Engine!” banana.

    I hate that that’s the way I get my kids to eat better but it works. It’s probably not a sign of the coming apocolypse, but maybe it can be a means to an end. Start by letting them have the Disney grapes (or brand your own), then switch to regular ol’ grapes down the line, once you know which variety your kids prefer.

    The part that gets me about the whole branding thing is that they are also branding eggs. EGGS! I mean really now.

  4. 4 mamazakka May 4, 2009 at 7:31 pm

    Wooooo-ooo, good one! And thanks for the great link, Frances! Too bad issue #13 isn’t available anymore, I think I want to own it!

  5. 5 Jennifer May 4, 2009 at 9:03 pm

    Putting Tinkerbell’s picture on a bag of carrots is pretty subtle marketing in my book. First, how often do kids actually see the bag? Second, if they’re too young to read, then all that impacts them is the image — not the call to action.

    My daughter is currently eating a stick of mozzarella cheese with a High School Musical picture on it. (On the wrapper, I mean, not on the cheese itself!) She hasn’t noticed. She’s too intent on figuring out how to open it!

  6. 6 Kirsten May 5, 2009 at 1:08 am

    I think my head exploded before yours did. I don’t think we’ll be falling for the marketing, what with my food coming from CSAs and a locally owned health food market that is not very likely to carry disney produce. Besides my kids don’t do tv or movies, so they don’t have a relationship to any of these characters. as I often tell them: “we live under a rock, you know!”

    LEt me know what you come up with. I’m fascinated.

  7. 7 TC May 5, 2009 at 3:50 am

    It’s a sign that we’re finally starting to really walk the healthy walk, and the corporations are scrambling to catch up. Those of us already on the local/homegrown bandwagon aren’t going to start buying SpongeBob pineapples, but those who wouldn’t know a papaya from a Twinkie just might! I won’t say it’s all good, but it’s all…better.

  8. 8 Alyson May 5, 2009 at 6:23 am

    Hahahahhahahaha, you had me at the title.

  9. 9 Vikki May 5, 2009 at 4:33 pm

    I will ponder this as I devour this delicious Hannah Montana Banana. Somehow, it just tastes better than regular bananas.

  10. 10 Ali May 6, 2009 at 12:47 am

    Love the discussion, and Alyson, I’m glad you picked up on the title.

    But…wait. Whaa??? SpongeBob carrots have been around for SIX YEARS? The rest of you have seen Tinkerbell grapes and HSM cheese sticks? Where the heck have I been?

    Oh, that’s right. Rural Vermont. Anyhow, I may try an experiment with my little eat-nothing Charlotte. Will she be more likely to eat a food that begins with a Disney sticker? Yes. I can already anticipate the results. Yes she will.

    Frances, thanks for the link. Fascinating stuff.

  11. 11 Jennifer Taggart, TheSmartMama May 7, 2009 at 3:04 am

    Holy carp the inside of your brain sounds like the inside of my brain.

    My daughter wants anything that is pink. Or has a pony. Screw the Disney princesses. My daugther wants Pepto Bismol only because it is pink. She wants beets because they are pink. Pink bananas . . . that would rock.

  12. 12 Billie May 7, 2009 at 2:57 pm

    Hmm… after trying to spend some fruitless moments explaining to my son that characters and toys in boxes are just tricks by the company to get your to buy something you wouldn’t normally buy… I wonder if I should just give in and slap stickers on produce.

    It is hard to get him to eat anything that is labeled a vegetable but he sure is a sucker for marketing so maybe this would work.

    But do I really want to encourage his consumerism? At 6, he is already the perfect little consumer wanting only Ben10 shoes and Spiderman shirts.

    I simply have to throw my hands up in despair because I have such little influence over him and his parents don’t have the same attitude that I have.


Comments are currently closed.



Archives


Crazy Hip Blog Mamas Web Ring

Join :: List :: Random

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 29 other followers