I would not eat them were they steamed
I would not eat them were they creamed
I would not eat them with the soy
Nor would you so don’t be coy
I would not eat them were they baked
I would not eat them in a cake
I could not eat them, Ali dear
I could not eat them without fear
- commenter Vikki, on brussels sprouts
Vikki, you made me laugh out loud, but you didn’t stop me. Thanks to all of you, I’ve got a few more recommendations for making the sprouts, as well as reports from my first two attempts. Note: more recipes welcome — good recipes are always welcome here! — though for Vikki’s sake, I will soon take a break from brussels sprouts for a bit.
By far, the most common recommendation was roasting. I got lots and lots of recommendations for roasted brussels sprouts. Mamasutra kicked off the roasting suggestions:
Oven roasted brusselsprouts, that’s my suggestion. Haven’t done it in a while, couldn’t give you temp. or time advice, but I’m sure it’s google-able, and they’re good, much better than the boiled ones I grew up eating.
Greg (whose recipe for Mediterranean kale salad, by the way, will be posted soon, along with pictures of the process) agrees:
Roasting Brussels Sprouts is great! Try trimming them, letting them soak in salty lemon water for 10 or 15 minutes, and then coating them in oil (or melted butter if you feel decadent) before you pop them into a preheated pan in the oven.
Bananafana took a break from planning next year’s garden to tell me:
I trim the ends, take off yellow leaves, mix with olive oil and kosher salt, and put in the oven at 400 until they’re brown (with a little black) 30 to 45 minutes. this is the only way anyone in our house will eat them. make sure you get them good and brown!
And Courtney says:
I second the recommendation for roasting the brusselsprouts. With salt, pepper, a little olive oil, mayhap a slice of bacon if you’re feeling frisky. But the one thing that made brussels sprouts palatable for me was to finely slice them (before roasting). I never liked the feeling of an entire tiny cabbage in my mouth, but finely sliced gives them a lovely texture. A little more work, but it’s not prohibitive.
Rebeccah, my very-good-friend-who’s-too-far-away-while-her-hubby-is-on-sabbatical-and-yeah-I-know-it’s-a-great-opportunity-for-him-but-damn-we-miss-you, recommends a recipe for Chicken Sausages Roasted with Potatoes and Brussels Sprouts, from Epicurious. (we’re trying this one this weekend - will let you know).
Charlotte, who like me, tends to get tiny crushes on men who rock her food world, (but who, unlike me, can stomach tomato aspic) mixes it up with a sautee-then-roast strategy:
Put some chunky pieces of pancetta and cook in a cast iron skillet until crispy. Pull them out and toss in brusselsprouts that have been trimmed and cut in half. Saute for a few minutes, put the pancetta back in and put the whole thing in a hot oven — 425 or so, until the sprouts are all brown and toasty on the outside. (Or if you’re really feeling lazy, you can throw the pancetta chunks and halved sprouts in the skillet, put in the hot oven and stir occasionally until they’re all crispy and cooked through. Yum. (Because everything’s better with pork fat).
My own mama, ever the dissenter, says:
Don’t dismiss microwaved brussels sprouts. Yes, garlic oven roasted sprouts are yummy, but when you are in a hurry microwave till semi soft in covered dish with only a sprinkle of water. Then toss with olive oil and Spike. Tasty.
Irrelevant Aside #1: back in my vegetarian days in high school, I used to carry Spike seasoning in my purse, which was not a purse, really, but rather a grey, drab Swiss army-style shoulder bag, because I was that stylish. Anyhow, I actually haven’t had Spike for years, though Kalyn’s Kitchen suggests that this might be a mistake.
Joanna recommends a steam-then sautee strategy, with her oft-eaten recipe from Farmer John:
Steam halved brussels sprouts for 5 minutes. In saute pan, heat olive oil. Saute sprouts cut side down (with salt and pepper) for 3-4 minutes until they brown, then add bread crumbs. Cook another 2 minutes. Plate and grate fresh Parmigiano Reggiano over the top. I had them last night, and two nights ago, and a day last week.
And then I got this email from Wendy, which I have to say was a little like reading a foreign language:
Not sure if you are a fan of crawfish but I started adding brussels sprouts to our big boils. They are quite tasty so now when having them as a side I put them on the stove to boil with shrimp/crawfish boiling seasoning (I use Zataran’s Pro Boil but Tony Zacheries would work). After removing from water I add a little butter. This is only good if you are a fan of spicy foods though.
Reading that, I was like, huh? Zataran’s? Tony Zacheries? crawfish boiling season? Say what? Je ne parle pas le Zataran! These are not terms we’re familiar with up here in rural Vermont. Irrelevant Aside #2: the phrase “big boil” makes me think about that thing that Blair got on his neck when we lived in Africa — the thing everybody thought was a goiter, and that we wound up naming “Yapo,” after Yapo Boni Auguste, the chief of the first village we lived in, and the only man we thought would be able to cure it (this, after Yapo Boni Auguste miraculously cured Blair’s problem foot — the foot that modern medicine had utterly failed to fix — in a matter of minutes). Ah, yes. That was a big boil, and it was something to behold. But wait. That’s more information than you need. Moving on. Anyhow, Wendy’s area code, 713, was included with her email, so I looked it up: Houston. Then I did a little research and found out that in Southeast Texas, crawfish boils are a hugely popular thing — they are a kind of gulf-area backyard barbecue. And they’re simple: crawfish, potatoes, corn, and spice. And maybe brussels sprouts. I might try my own version up here, though I don’t think we can get crawfish in Southern Vermont - maybe a shrimp boil, then? Anyhow, thanks, Wendy, for expanding my horizons.
Jenn’s recommendation is the last one I’ll mention here, though it is the first that arrived in my box. She recommends a method from Heidi Swanson, whose cookbook, Super Natural Cooking, she says is “highly highly recommended for healthy recipes, all of which have turned out to be family pleasers” (not the first time I’ve heard this; it’s now on my wish list).
Take fresh, relatively small brussels sprouts. Peel out any unsightly outer leaves. Cut in half lengthwise.
Heat some olive oil (not too much - enough to cover the bottom of the pan) on medium heat. Put the brussels sprouts in flat side down. Let cook 5-8 minutes, until lightly browned on the bottom. Remove once as browned as you prefer (I like them very brown, although Heidi recommends them only lightly browned). She also recommends paramesean cheese, which I didn’t bother with. They were excellent without cheese (I don’t even recognize me as I say this - cheese, like salt, goes with almost everything).
Anyway, this was the first time that we’d tried Brussels sprouts (we had a CSA, and discovered many vegetables that were new to us. Still working on the celeriac…) and we’ve had them this way at least a 1/2 dozen times. A complete (but welcome) surprise. We didn’t think that we’d like turnips, either…
Jenn’s was the first one I tried, because (a) it arrived first, and (b) because it had only three core ingredients, all of which I had on hand: olive oil, salt, and brussels sprouts. Look, I sliced and sauteed:

And when they were brown, like this, I ate them:

That’s when I realized: getting the sprouts brown is the trick. You don’t want to overcook them, as then they release sulphur, and become icky-smelling. But browning? It does something really yummy. That, I now believe, is the key. Blair and I both ate these (”yeah, these aren’t too bad,” he said, which believe me is a huge improvement over seeing him scrape uneaten vegetables into the bin). The kids didn’t try them, because we chose to eat in peace, and gobbled them up as the wee ones slept.
By the way, my second attempt was with Orangette’s recipe. I chose hers, because her blog, and her State of the Sprout post, were just so beautiful. It’s kind of the same reason people run out to get Jennifer Lopez hairstyles — if I just do this one thing, I’ll look like her, too! — well, Orangette is kind of my J.Lo. Her sprouts were pretty good, actually (subtle, but tasty, particularly the next day, after the flavors had some time to set), but unfortunately they didn’t make my ass blog look like hers.

Irrelevant Aside #3: am I the only one who thinks that the sprouts scattered a little bit in the shape of the map of the United States?
And check it out: as I was doing a little recipe on brussels sprouts, I discovered that I’m not the only one who needed help. Looks like Bonnie, of the fabulous Ethicurean, went through the same process a little under a year ago (right before I discovered her). She asked for help, and she learned to like the little buggers.
So, Vikki, you never know:
You do not like them, so you boast
But you may like them in a roast
You may like them in a boil,
or sauteed with salt and olive oil!
You may like them in a hash
With lemon juice (though just a splash!)
You just might like them slightly browned.
They’re not too bad, as Bonnie found!
You do not like them.
So you say.
Try them! Try them!
And you may.
Try them and you may, I say.